#9
Carlos is a good choice, but I would have to go with Freddie Glover of the Barons.
Also, while it is hard to go against Bob Lemon, just from a Cleveland perspective, and what he meant to the town, I'd have to give #21 to Rocky Colavito.
Rocky started wearing #6 in 1958 with his first stint in Cleveland
In 1965 after returning back to Cleveland Rocky wore #21
Lemon can keep 21....put Rocky in #6